Thursday, November 26, 2015


GRAVE MISTAKE by Ngaio Marsh (1978)

Reviewed by Andrea Thompson 

Fifty-year-old Verity Preston lives in the small village of Upper Quintern, where she grew up. Although she spent much of her adult life working in theatre production, she returned to live in Upper Quintern five years previously, when her prosperous father died and left her his house. This has enabled Verity to live quite pleasantly, taking care of the house and writing plays, an occupation which has provided her with moderate success.

One of Verity’s oldest friends in the little village is Sybil Foster, a well-off, flirtatious widow, who is in many ways Verity’s opposite. Where Verity is quiet, detached, and observant, Sybil throws herself in the middle of things, loves to attract attention, and makes much of her various illnesses. As well as being outgoing, Sybil is a controlling, demanding woman, who has firm ideas about the potential marriage of her young daughter, Prunella.

As the story begins, the village is experiencing some shake-ups. The gardener used by many of the better-off residents has died unexpectedly, resulting in his replacement by a vigorous man whose last name is, fittingly, Gardener. As well, Nikolas Markos and his son Gideon have recently moved to Upper Quintern, and Gideon’s handsome looks are causing Sybil concern, as she feels Prunella is much too interested in the young man.

There is sort of a timeless mood to this Alleyn book. Although Marsh specifies that it is after WWII, it’s not clear exactly what year the book is set in. People are concerned with rising taxes and the difficulties in getting domestic help, and people’s fashions seems a bit groovy – Nikolas and Gideon are wearing velvet coats when they host a dinner party. But there is still a sharp distinction between working class and upper-middle class in the story.

As is typical of many of Marsh’s books, it takes quite some time for Alleyn to arrive, as the mystery is carefully set up with various plausible suspects. When Alleyn does show up in the village to investigate a murder, Verity is struck by how distinguished he is, and Alleyn also seems impressed by Verity’s common sense and integrity. Alleyn mixes, mostly smoothly, with his suspects – charming but persistent, polite but relentless. He is accompanied by his colleagues Fox, Thompson, and Bailey, who get busy interviewing, dusting for fingerprints, and taking photographs.

Possibly the strongest part of this later Marsh book is the dialogue, although the plot is good as well.  But the dialogue is fresh and energized. Many of the exchanges between characters are quite funny, particularly with the somewhat flighty Prunella, who tends to whisper rather than speak at a normal volume. And there is a very amusing scene towards the end of the story, when Alleyn winds up in a bar with a drunken doctor and nurse, trying to corral them into telling the truth.

Alleyn in the 1970s remains as reassuring, calm, reliable, and committed as he has been throughout the decades – always middle-aged, experienced, competent and smooth – and yet never losing sight of what is most important: catching the murderer and seeing justice done.


Andrea is an avid mystery reader from Ontario who loves crime fiction, both old and new, with a passion. She says she is drawn to mysteries because they focus on the search for truth. You can visit her Facebook book review page here

Wednesday, November 25, 2015


SLEEP OF REASON by Rose Beecham (Bold Stroke Books, 2006)

Reviewed by Megan Casey

When a small boy is kidnapped from his home, most of Montezuma County turns out for the search. But nothing is as it seems with this case, and Detective Jude Devine soon finds herself caught up in a small-town soap opera whose players seem more interested in their 15 minutes of fame than in the fate of little Corban.

The second book in the Jude Devine series is a worthy successor to the first. Maybe more so, as author Rose Beecham doesn't have Fundamentalist Mormon sects to bash. Instead, she sets her sights on child abuse. A two-year-old boy goes missing from his home while the mother is out and her boyfriend babysits. Everyone in the book—and every reader—knows that the boyfriend is responsible, but he is somehow able to pile lie on top of lie to wiggle out of every inconsistency in his story.

The book reminds me more than a little of Katherine V. Forrest’s Murder by Tradition, where the murderer keeps changing his story every few minutes without actually convicting himself. Another comparison is that it is partly a courtroom drama, where the story plays out in the man’s trial, although with a much different conclusion. Beecham's style is not dissimilar to Forrest's and their protagonists are similarly aloof.

Jude’s relationship with Dr. Mercy Westmoreland goes way south when the good doctor decides to marry her English movie-star lover in a large, well-publicized ceremony (I wonder what happened to Mercy’s fear of being outed in the small Colorado town where she still works?). I never thought they were particularly well suited anyway. The good news is that Chastity Young—a character from the first book—drives back into Jude’s life and wins her heart. Her difficulty with sex will undoubtedly be brought out further in the next book in the series.

Another subplot here is the relationship between two new characters, Brenda and Lonewolf. Lone, unbeknownst to Brenda, is planning to assassinate Dick Cheney for helping move the U.S. into an unreasonable war--one that ultimately cost the life of Lone's previous lover. Jude suspects Lone of plotting something, but she isn't sure what. We'll undoubtedly find out next time.

As in the first book, there is a lot in the actual plot that doesn't actually make sense, but as I keep saying, we tend to overlook all but the more major plot glitches with the writing is good and the characters interesting. As they are in Sleep of Reason.

Megan Casey is an avid booklover from Billings, Montana. Born in Canada and raised in the Pacific Northwest, Megan studied English literature and library management, and has worked as a book editor and librarian. She moderates the "Lesbian Mysteries" group onGood Reads, and created the website The Art of the Lesbian Mystery Novel

Tuesday, November 24, 2015


THE MISTAKE by Grant Nicol (Number 13 Press, 2015)

Reviewed by Craig Sisterson 

A mutilated body is found on a lonely street in Reykjavík. Detective Grímur intends to see that justice is done. Kjartan Jónsson vows that his daughter’s killer will be punished. And that the punishment will fit the crime. Prime suspect Gunnar Atli desperately needs to prevent his own dark secrets from coming to light. And he’s not the only one. 

THE MISTAKE was the first story from Iceland-based Kiwi author Grant Nicol that I've read. It won't be the last. Diving into this novella on a train journey in the UK, I found myself completely absorbed by Nicol's prose and storytelling. Hooked early, intrigued throughout.

Set in Nicol's adopted hometown of Reykjavik, THE MISTAKE has a simple but very effective set-up. There's been a brutal murder. There's a clear prime suspect - the very troubled man prone to blackouts who claims he just stumbled across the body. A cop and a bereaved father both want justice, but of vastly different kinds. Several people, all with secrets, collide.

Nicol does a superb job taking this premise and layering in a lot of complexities and intrigue. Beyond the "just what really happened - did Gunnar Atli do it or not?" hook, we are taken down a number of rabbit holes, as Nicol guides us into the darker parts of Icelandic society. Prostitution, treatment of the mentally ill, domestic troubles, crime and justice. Nordic Noir with a strong emphasis on the NOIR.

This is a very good crime tale.

Part of Number 13 Press's monthly series of high quality crime novellas, THE MISTAKE is small but perfectly formed. 150 pages that pack quite a punch, and leaves the reader reeling at times.

Being a novella, there isn't room for a massive amount of character development, but I felt that Nicol did a good job bring some depth to those involved; they were more than ciphers or caricatures, even if it is a very plot and atmosphere-focused tale. There's a real creepy sense to THE MISTAKE, a story of things going badly wrong in a world where bad things happen, beneath the snowy and peaceful veneer of Iceland.

Reading THE MISTAKE almost reminded me of those classic horror movies, which were brooding and creepy more than bloody and slasher-like. Absorbing, atmospheric, and suspenseful - powered by dark situations getting even darker as events unfold. Where the worst things happened off-screen, and were left to our imaginations, fuelling that gut-clenching psychological fear rather than blood-filled splatter and visuals.

Nicol is a talented storyteller who takes us on a short, but very good, ride.


I've recently become aware of a brand new debut New Zealand psychological thriller, which is having its official book launch at the Women's Bookshop in Ponsonby tonight NZT.

Carole Beu and her team at the Women's Bookshop regularly put on terrific events (I've attended some in the past with the likes of Tess Gerritsen and Val McDermid) and are great supporters of good books and great writing. I'd highly recommend anyone near Auckland heads along tonight for the launch of THE GENTLEMEN'S CLUB.

Jen Shieff's debut novel sounds very promising. A former government analyst, Turangi-based Shieff has delved into some real-life New Zealand history with her historical psychological thriller, that sounds like it might mix a few genres and appeal to a range of readers.

Here's the official blurb:
A psychological thriller that will shock you to the core. Headstrong and independent, Rita Saunders is a successful hairdresser by day and a busy brothel madam by night. The only thing missing from her life is the love of a good woman. Istvan Ziegler is a Hungarian immigrant who has come to New Zealand to work on the brand new harbour bridge project. He is full of hope and dreams of a better life. Sixteen-year-old Judith Curran has come to Auckland for an abortion. With no money or family support, she finds herself at the mercy of strangers and simply has to hope they have her best interests at heart. Becoming bound into a desperate situation involving a group of orphan girls, Rita, Judith and Istvan find fortitude they never knew they possessed. But do they have enough of it to expose the menacing orphanage director and the slice of the heartless and seedy 1950s' underworld he inhabits? The Gentlemen's Club is an honest and gritty debut novel that will linger with you long after you have finished reading it.
I understand the book launch tonight is open to anyone, and kicks off from 6pm.


THE DEVIL'S WIRE by Deborah Rogers (2015)

Reviewed by Mark McGinn

What’s worse than running over your neighbor’s dog? If you read THE DEVIL'S WIRE by Deborah Rogers, you’ll find out! There are surprises aplenty in this rollicking read and you might at the end, look carefully at what you really know about those closest to you. Are they who they really seem?

There’s a small cast of characters in this book but they’re all beautifully drawn by Rogers. Blunt South African antagonist, Lenise Jameson, is a bit of a favourite of mine. She provides endless suffering for protagonist Jennifer, seemingly for the careless killing of her dog who’d somehow gotten on to the road on a dark night at the very time Jennifer was concerned about not having an accident. Jennifer had been trying to rescue a loose mandarin from under foot.

But empathy for the life situation of both women is not difficult. Guilt ridden Jennifer’s relationship with needy husband Hank, is at best, running aground, and at worst, revealing a nightmare. Their only child, 12 year old McKenzie, has hateful rages towards her mother, largely it seems, due to Jennifer’s ignorance of what has been going on in the family home. Rogers is clever in showing us Jennifer’s psychology throughout e.g. sentences that paint a picture of a frantic and unsettled mind.

Meanwhile, Lenise with an adult son who does her no credit, is bereaved by the loss of her beloved pooch and soon finds herself on hard times. Early in the story Lenise is set up by an immoral rival to be fired from her real estate job. But her inability to sustain any meaningful relationship with a human being is not only down to a clumsy penchant for unsolicited advice. Her biggest flaw, one she is blind to, is her obsession about McKenzie, the daughter she wanted and never had. The more she wants that type of love and affection, the more she acts to prevent it.

Jennifer and Lenise, so different in their own way, become an unholy and dangerous alliance. They drive a carefully crafted and twisting plot that will have you on edge wondering how they get out of a horrible mess of their own creation.

When you take the characters, the plot and the liberally infused shades of dark humor, you’ll likely be wondering when you’ll be treated to more of the fine writing craft of Deborah Rogers.

Mark McGinn has published three crime novels. Based in Christchurch, he worked for many years in the New Zealand court system. You can find out more about him and his writing here

Monday, November 23, 2015


INSIDE THE BLACK HORSE by Ray Berard (Mary Egan, 2015)

Reviewed by Craig Sisterson

An armed robbery interrupts a drug deal, igniting a compelling crime tale powered by intriguing characters that has a good feel for life in rural and small-town modern New Zealand. 

Toni Bourke is treading water, trying not to drown, as she operates the Black Horse pub in Rotorua. She's determined to keep the tills ringing as the months pass since the sudden loss of her husband, relying on the penchant of locals for both drinking and gambling while they socialise.

Outside in the dark, Pio Morgan nervously prepares himself. He's had a tough life and comes from a tough family, but he's not a tough guy. Duped by a local pot grower, he's backed into a corner, desperate for money. The lure of the Black Horse pub, with its treasure trove of pokie and TAB losings, is strong.

Gun in hand, Pio enters the pub. A moment of madness upends so many lives, lighting the fuse on a violent chain of events that pulls in locals and others from far away. Intertwined lives. Not all will survive.

Ray Berard's first published crime novel is a real cracker. An exciting beginning pulls the reader in, but it's the nice touch Berard has for a fascinating and diverse cast of characters, along with the way he revokes rural and small-town New Zealand life, that blends with the action and mystery to really elevate INSIDE THE BLACK HORSE to must-read crime novel territory. I wasn't sure what to expect when I started - Berard was a new author, a Canadian immigrant to New Zealand, setting a book in the central North Island. An area that combines tourist-enticing scenery with a blue-collar population and strong Maori influence.

For me, INSIDE THE BLACK HORSE started well and got even better as it went along, with Berard layering in depth to the characters and story as the action unfolded. I was curious at first, then intrigued, then enthralled. There was a good sense of balance between character and plot, with some interesting underlying themes and a well-evoked setting, sociologically and geographically.

This debut crime novel felt 'well-rounded', for want of a better phrase.

I understand that Berard is a former TAB supervisor (that's a New Zealand betting agency that has outlets all across the country, often attached to pubs and bars), and his experience and knowledge of the intricacies of that industry is well utilised. He does a great job evoking life in small-town New Zealand, including the focal point of the 'local', where various people from the community all meet to drink (and some to gamble), along with threading in the symbiosis between blue collar locals who keep the tills ringing and the 'corporate suits' in big city head offices who are focused more on numbers, bottom lines, and perceptions.

In some ways INSIDE THE BLACK HORSE feels like a snapshot of modern-day New Zealand, populated by a range of authentic characters: hard-working people, blue collar and white collar, bludgers, gang members, cops and criminals. The weak and the wounded, the courageous and the strong. Those trying to do right by their family and those willing to sacrifice others to get ahead. Everyone trying to survive.

Even when I thought I could see where INSIDE THE BLACK HORSE was going, plot-wise, Berard did a nice job at throwing in a few surprises, crafting an engaging story that felt fresh and unique even as it delivered the kinds of things fans of crime fiction expect and like to see from the genre.

Great characters, good action, some nice prose. A surprisingly excellent local crime thriller, and the best debut New Zealand crime novel I've read in a few years. Highly recommended.

9mm interview with Leonie Mateer

Puppeteer, children's entertainer, owner of a model agency, TV talk show panelist, luxury accommodation owner, entrepreneur: storyteller Leonie Mateer has lived a full and diverse life. Born and raised in New Zealand, Mateer moved to the United States in her 30s to pursue business opportunities. She returned to New Zealand for several years in the 2000s, running a luxury lodge in Northland - which has been an inspiration for her crime series - and now splits her time between Northland and the United States. Today, she becomes the 135th author in our 9mm series.

Mateer is known for her huge success as a brand development expert, and has previously written business advice books. She was named in the 'Who's Who' of both Leading American Executives and American Inventors in the 1990s. A lifelong storyteller, she published THE MURDER SUITE, her first adult thriller, last year, kickstarting a series starring Audrey, "a psychopath, a serial killer and a friendly resident in a small town in rural Northland". The series has continued with THE CABIN BY THE SEA (Book 2) and THE MURDER TRAIL (Book 3).

But for now Leonie Mateer becomes the latest crime writer to stare down the barrel of 9mm.


1. Who is your favourite recurring crime fiction hero/detective, and what is it you love about them?
As a constant traveler, I would consume large quantities of “best sellers” from airport gift shops often being drawn to suspense thrillers from authors such as Stephen King and John Saul.

Kathy Bates character in Misery and “Dexter” are two of my favorite crime characters. I find the perpetrators of the crimes much more interesting than the detectives on their case. Dexter’s psychopathic personality enables him to live in both worlds – as a killer and as a forensic analyst. His everyday normality and his lack of remorse or guilt I find both fascinating and creepy.

2. What was the very first book you remember reading and really loving, and why?
With no doubt it would be Hansel and Gretel. I grew up on fairy tales.  I loved the dark side of fairy tales. Two children alone in the forest, tempted by the candy cottage only to be trapped in a cage by a wicked witch… all the elements of a great story.

3. Before your debut crime novel, what else had you written (if anything) - unpublished manuscripts, short stories, articles?
My first book was The Caboodles Blueprint, a “how-to” business book.  I still continue to blog on subjects ranging from the creative process of product development to taking your product to the worldwide market.

When I was a little girl I used to tell my younger brother “made-up scary stories” every night in the dark. So it was no surprise to find that my first fictional novel was a children’s fantasy thriller The Magical World of Dantonia.

4. Outside of writing, and touring and promotional commitments, what do you really like to do, leisure and activity-wise?
I always need a “project” and one that is a challenge. My projects are as diverse as my interests. I like to tackle projects that require learning a new skill such as creating a tropical fruit tree orchard, sewing new pastures for grazing sheep, learning the challenges of social media marketing, converting old buildings into dwellings and visiting my family whoare scattered worldwide – just to name a few.

5. What is one thing that visitors to your hometown should do, that isn't in the tourist brochures, or perhaps they wouldn’t initially consider?
The far north of New Zealand is one of the most beautiful places in the world and, unfortunately, is not on the popular “tourist route.” White sandy beaches, pristine harbours, rolling green hills spotted with cattle and sheep, dense native bush, kiwi reserves and native birds are just some of the wonders of the winterless north.

6. If your life was a movie, which actor could you see playing you?
Bette Midler (USA) or Judi Dench (UK)

7. Of your writings, which is your favourite, and why?
I wrote a small piece one day about a little boy given the “talking stick” in his classroom.  Owning the stick gave him a few minutes to talk and be heard by the other children in the circle before passing it on. To capture the moment in prose kept it forever in my minds eye reminding me how precious it is to be listened to when there is something you want to tell.

8. What was your initial reaction, and how did you celebrate, when you were first accepted for publication? Or when you first saw your debut story in book form?
I received a contract to publish my business book when I was in Ventura, California with my two pre teen grandsons. We joined hands and danced in sheer joy. They were so proud of their “Bubba” and I was so happy to share this wonderful moment with them.

9. What is the strangest or most unusual experience you have had at a book signing, author event, or literary festival?
My first book signing event was in Ventura, California and was remarkably successful due to family and friends in full attendance. I talked, they laughed, they bought books and the store manager was pleased.

My second book signing was in Malibu on the first sunny day of the season. Crowds went to the beach and empty chairs greeted me in the bookstore. A sprinkling of disinterested customers obliged me by taking a seat to hear my short presentation. I could feel their disappointment when they realized my book was a business book and not a great mystery or sultry romance, so I cut my reading short and handed out chocolates instead.

Thank you Leonie, we appreciate you taking the time to chat to Crime Watch

You can read more about Leonie Mateer, including sample chapters from her crime novels, at her website here
You can follow her on Twitter here or find her crime novels for sale here


THE DARKEST DAY by Tom Wood (Signet, 2015)

Reviewed by Craig Sisterson

A loner anti-hero quicksteps his way through murky alliances while looking to avoid landmines in this high-octane thriller that keeps the needle high as it hurtles across continents to a New York showdown. 

Victor kills people for a living, and is damned good at his job. At the top of the tree, utilised by all sorts, including the CIA, for dirty jobs they need to get done. But he knows that one day it will be his turn (his enemies are legion, past and new), and is constantly assessing risks wherever he goes.

Paranoid, ruthless, highly skilled, Victor draws readers in not because he's an admirable guy but because he's extremely good at what he does, and gets himself into and out of some really exciting situations. THE DARKEST DAY, the fifth in Wood's series, is an unapologetic, out-and-out airport thriller. Fast-paced, foot-to-the-floor action with some tremendous set pieces, it's an extremely exciting read. Wood does a great job crafting a slickly told story that threads in some strands of character, setting, and philosophy, but really this is all about the page-whirring action and thrills. It's a compelling ride.

Victor is set to take out a terrorist financier in Prague, but instead finds himself scampering for survival from a dangerous rival, Raven. Was he set up by his paymasters, or has his own past come back to haunt him?

Knowing he can't let this threat continue to exist, Victor hunts Raven across the globe, trying to establish who sent her and why she came after him at this time. A man who only trusts himself, he knows those around him are lying to him - but which lies are the most dangerous, and how does he sort through the deceit?

Wood has us clinging to Victor's coat-tails as the enigmatic assassin careens from Europe to Latin America to New York City, where a showdown looms. But who is the real enemy, and what do they want? As darkness falls across the Big Apple, Victor realises he might only be a pawn in something far greater.

At times THE DARKEST DAY reads like a novel-length car chase, and it walks a tightrope of going overboard on that front, but overall I found the book to be an exciting, engaging read with a 'cool' main character.  I'd imagine fans of Jack Reacher or Jason Bourne would really enjoy what is a very fast-paced thriller that feels like it would be an ideal all-action tale for the big screen. Visual storytelling with enough intrigue laced in throughout the action to keep your mind wondering as your heart races.

Recommended for thriller fans.